Healthy Cream Cheese Frosting – (No Butter or Shortening!)

This healthy cream cheese frosting recipe is light, fluffy, and naturally sweetened. You will love the soft, whipped texture and tangy cream cheese flavor!

Healthy Tofu Cream Cheese Frosting Recipe

What makes this the best healthy cream cheese frosting?

No butter, no shortening, and no powdered sugar.
One simple trick makes the frosting so much thicker and fluffier than similar recipes.
It tastes like cheesecake you can eat with a spoon.
Perfect for topping carrot cake, cupcakes, red velvet cake, or cinnamon rolls!
You need just four ingredients, with low calorie, dairy free, gluten free, sugar free, low carb, vegan, and keto options all included.

Try it on this Carrot Cake Banana Bread

Step by step recipe video

Key ingredients

Yogurt or Tofu – Greek yogurt or soft tofu both work well to add thickness and creaminess. As a bonus, low fat yogurt and tofu are high in protein and low in saturated fat. For vegan cream cheese frosting, use dairy free yogurt or the silken tofu option.

Cream Cheese – You can buy block or whipped Philadelphia cream cheese (reduced fat or regular), soy free cashew cream cheese, or store bought or homemade vegan cream cheese.

Unrefined Sugar – Many healthy cream cheese frosting recipes call for pure maple syrup or honey. While you can use one of those here, the consistency of the icing will be thinner. For the best fluffy texture, I like to start with raw cane sugar and pulse in a blender or food processor until fine and powdery. Voila! An easy, healthier alternative to processed powdered sugar.

Vanilla Extract – A teaspoon of pure vanilla extract balances the tanginess of the cream cheese.

Ground Cinnamon (optional) – Add up to a half teaspoon of cinnamon for cozy warmth and sweetness without a ton of extra calories. A pinch of chai or pumpkin pie spice is also lovely.

Cinnamon Rolls With Healthy Cream Cheese Icing

Above, healthy cream cheese frosting tastes delicious spread on Easy Cinnamon Rolls.

Cream cheese frosting health benefits

No trans fats, artificial flavors or colors.
Unlike store bought frosting, this one has no corn syrup.
An equal size serving of Pillsbury cream cheese frosting contains more calories, more fat, no protein, and over four times the amount of sugar!
Close to two grams protein in just one tablespoon.
Provides calcium and iron.
Yogurt or tofu takes the place of all the butter in traditional frosting, adding creaminess and texture without all the unhealthy fat.

Greek Yogurt Cream Cheese Frosting Recipe

How to make yogurt cream cheese frosting

Step 1: Soften the cream cheese. Let the cream cheese sit out on the counter for up to an hour ahead of time. This step is especially important if you are using blocks, because it will blend more easily and smoothly when soft.

Step 2: Make healthy powdered sugar. If you are using granulated sugar, blend it alone in a food processor until it turns to fine powder.

Step 3: Combine all ingredients. Add the tofu or yogurt, softened cream cheese, powdered sweetener, pure vanilla extract, and optional cinnamon to a food processor or stand mixer. It also works in a large bowl with hand beaters.

Step 4: Blend until smooth. Process on high, stopping occasionally to scrape down the sides of the machine. Continue blending until the mixture is thick, whipped, and super fluffy.

Step 5: Chill if desired. You can serve the healthy cream cheese icing straight away, or refrigerate until cold if you prefer a firmer texture. It will also be much more firm after sitting loosely covered in a bowl overnight in the fridge. If time permits, I love making the recipe a day in advance.

Turn it into different flavors

In addition to the aforementioned cinnamon, and chocolate and lemon variations (below), you can create endless custom frosting flavors from the base recipe.

High Protein Frosting: Blend in two tablespoons of your favorite flavored protein powder.

Maple Cream Cheese Frosting: Add two drops of maple extract. Taste, then slowly add more drops if you want a stronger maple flavor.

This idea works for peppermint, coconut, or almond extract as well.

Pumpkin Cream Cheese Frosting: Replace a fourth cup of the Greek yogurt or tofu with canned pumpkin puree. Include the optional cinnamon, as well as a fourth teaspoon of ground pumpkin spice.

Peanut Butter Frosting: Replace at least one fourth cup of the Greek yogurt or tofu with creamy peanut butter. Almond butter, pecan butter, or cashew butter work too.

Coffee Cream Cheese Icing: Blend in a teaspoon of instant coffee or espresso powder.

Low Calorie Cream Cheese Frosting (Healthy Recipe)

Frequently asked questions

Can you pipe this frosting?

While the frosting is thicker than similar healthier frostings, it contains no shortening or butter and is therefore not ideal for piping.

How do you make healthy chocolate cream cheese frosting?

This one is easy. Just blend one third cup sifted cocoa powder into the recipe, and increase the vanilla extract to one and a half teaspoons. Thin with a teaspoon or two milk of choice (or brewed coffee!) if needed.

Can you use vanilla yogurt?

Sure. You can try blueberry, strawberry, or lemon yogurt too. If using vanilla Greek yogurt, omit the vanilla extract in the recipe.

How do you store homemade cream cheese frosting?

Cover leftovers tightly and refrigerate for up to five days. The icing is free of preservatives, so it shouldn’t sit out at room temperature for more than a few hours.

In general, I do not recommend freezing homemade frostings, because the texture after thawing is never as creamy.

How to make nutella chocolate hazelnut spread

Easy Healthier Cream Cheese Frosting With Yogurt (No Shortening)

1. Let cream cheese sit at room temperature for up to an hour to soften, so it will blend more smoothly.
2. If using granulated sweetener, blend it alone in a food processor until it turns fine and powdery.
3. Process softened cream cheese, tofu or yogurt, sweetener, vanilla extract, and optional cinnamon in a food processor or stand mixer, or with hand beaters in a large bowl. Stop occasionally to scrape down the sides, and blend until smooth and fluffy.
4. Serve right away, or refrigerate until cold for a thicker texture. The healthy cream cheese frosting is also much firmer after sitting loosely covered overnight in the refrigerator.
5. Store any leftovers after a day in a tightly covered container in the refrigerator for up to five days.