There’s a sandwich, and then there’s a SANDWICH. You know the one… The kind where you take that first bite and everything just stops for a second. No boring deli counter stuff here. I’m talking mozzarella-stuffed burger patties, fried mac and cheese standing in as buns, and a banh mi so good it made it into my actual cookbook. These are the sandwiches I make when I want to treat my family to something truly special, when I’m packing up a picnic and want everyone to ooh and ahh when I unwrap it, or honestly, when I just need a little something extraordinary on an otherwise ordinary Tuesday. Over the years these recipes have become some of the most beloved in our house, and in yours, too, judging by your emails! Whether you’re a spice lover, a comfort food devotee, or just someone who believes a great sandwich deserves great bread, there’s something in this list for you. Let’s get into it!
1. Stuffed Caprese Burgers
We took all the magic of a fresh caprese salad and stuffed it right into the center of a juicy burger patty. Bite in and you get ooey gooey melted mozzarella, balsamic-sautéed onions, and fresh basil leaves all tucked inside a buttery brioche bun. It’s a burger made in Italian heaven, and your backyard barbecue will never be the same.
View Recipe →
2. Caramelized Pineapple Grilled Cheese
We call grilled cheese sandwiches ‘melties’ in our house, and this one is hands-down one of the best melties I’ve ever made. Sweet caramelized pineapple, a little heat from jalapeños, and creamy fontina cheese come together in the most unexpected, totally irresistible way. Once you try this combination, plain grilled cheese will feel like a step backward.
View Recipe →
3. Pressed Italian Picnic Sandwiches
Picnics are a family favorite of ours, and this pressed sandwich is the reason everyone looks forward to them. Pepperoncinis, sun-dried tomatoes, and a homemade pesto that is truly to die for get layered together and pressed until all those flavors marry into something absolutely spectacular. Slice it up and watch it disappear.
View Recipe →
4. Crispy Chicken Sandwich
Perfectly crispy on the outside, incredibly juicy on the inside, this is the chicken sandwich that makes you wonder why you ever went through a drive-through. It’s a classic comfort food done right, and it’s simpler to pull off than you’d think. Whether you’re a seasoned home cook or just getting started, this one delivers every single time.
View Recipe →
5. Juicy Smoked Burgers
Juicy smoked burgers are packed with deep, smoky flavor and cooked to perfection. Tender, flavorful, and perfect for piling high with your favorite toppings, they’re the kind of burgers that make any cookout feel like a win.
View Recipe →
6. The Ultimate Spicy Grilled Cheese
My husband is always asking for spicier dinners, and this sandwich was basically made for him. Sriracha onions, fresh jalapeños, pepper jack cheese, jalapeño chips for crunch, and even sriracha butter. It’s multiple layers of heat and flavor all at once. It burns your face off in the best possible way, and it tastes incredible doing it.
View Recipe →
7. Mac and Cheese Burger Buns
Hold on to your diets, folks, we’re replacing the burger bun with breaded, fried mac and cheese. Yes, really. It’s a heart attack on a plate and one of the most fun culinary adventures you’ll ever take in your own kitchen. Save this one for a special occasion and prepare to absolutely blow everyone’s minds.
View Recipe →
8. Queso Fundido Chorizo Burger
This queso fundido chorizo burger combines a chorizo-ground beef patty with gooey melted cheese, peppers, onions, and guacamole for a Mexican-inspired twist on the classic cheeseburger.
View Recipe →
9. Chipotle Black Bean Burgers
These Black Bean Burgers bring a little heat and all the flavor with chipotle, garlic, and ground cumin. You’ll never miss the beef with this burger!
View Recipe →
10. Fajita Burgers
Fajita Burgers take all the flavors of fajitas that you love and combine them into a delicious burger that’s perfect for any backyard barbecue!
View Recipe →
11. Ranch Burger
A burger so good it’s been known to steal hearts! This Ranch burger will win yours over too with all the bold and juicy flavor for a burger experience like no other.
View Recipe →
12. Slow Cooker Shredded Beef and Horseradish Sandwiches
Horseradish and tender, shredded beef make the perfect combination. Throw it in the slow cooker, put it on a bun, and dinner is done!
View Recipe →
13. Santa Fe Grilled Chicken Sandwich (Carl’s Jr. Copycat)
Santa Fe grilled chicken sandwich brings that bold, smoky flavor with juicy chicken, melty cheese, and all the good toppings stacked high. It’s a solid copycat that hits those same takeout cravings without leaving the house.
View Recipe →
14. Italian Beef Sandwiches
Italian Beef can be cooked in a slow cooker, instant pot, or seared on your stovetop and cooked in the oven. There is minimal prep time before it cooks low and slow with your favorite Italian spices for tender, juicy beef your entire family will love.
View Recipe →
15. Santa Fe Turkey Sliders
My Santa Fe Turkey Sliders have layers of turkey, pepperjack cheese, and green chiles on a bed of Hawaiian Rolls, but it’s my delicious Southwestern-inspired spread that takes these over the top!
View Recipe →
16. Mississippi Pot Roast Sliders
Mississippi pot roast sliders are juicy, buttery, and packed with bold flavor in every bite. Tender shredded beef piled onto soft rolls makes them perfect for parties, game days, or whenever you need something that disappears fast.
View Recipe →
17. Slow Cooker Creamy BBQ Chicken Sliders
Slow cooker creamy BBQ chicken sliders are saucy, cheesy, and ridiculously easy to pull together. Tender shredded chicken coated in creamy barbecue goodness piled onto soft buns makes these a go-to for feeding a crowd without the stress.
View Recipe →
18. Cheesesteak Sliders
Cheesesteak sliders are melty, savory, and piled high with flavor. Tender beef, sautéed peppers and onions, and plenty of gooey cheese tucked into soft rolls make these an easy crowd favorite.
View Recipe →
Some meals are meant to be neat, and these are not those meals. These sandwiches and burgers are all about big flavors, stacked layers, and not worrying about a little mess. Grab extra napkins, pick your favorite, and lean all the way in.