Strategic Menu Planning
Keep it simple: Offer one or two protein options rather than a variety. Pulled Pork served on buns with Pig Pucker Sauce is our first choice. Pork shoulder is inexpensive, can be smoked and pulled the day before the party, then reheated, and is always a crowd pleaser. Alternatively, chicken thighs feed many people economically and can be prepared ahead, then grilled during the party. For vegetarians, large portobello mushrooms or veggie skewers work well. Hot dogs for the kids? Why not?
To the “What can I bring” question, suggest an appetizer, side dish, or dessert. This will give your spread greater variety, lighten your burden as host, and more importantly, give your guests a share in your party’s success. Here’s our suggested menu, most of which can be made ahead:
Be Organized
As busy caterers will tell you, it’s very important to be organized when feeding a crowd. As the pit master, you’ll want everything at the ready. (A cheffy term for this is mise en place.) Avoid multiple runs to the kitchen to grab forgotten items. Appoint a helper.
If your grill does not have an attached workspace, set up a table—even a sturdy card table or picnic table will work—and stock it with a stack of foil pans, paper towels, heavy-duty foil, grill gloves, food-handling gloves, small bowls of coarse salt and pepper, vegetable oil, and long-handled tongs and spatulas. Don’t forget a good grill brush [LINK] as you may need to clean and oil the grill grate multiple times during the party. A fire extinguisher positioned near your cooking area will make you look like a pro.
Buffet (Self-Serve) Set-up
Arrange food stations to promote good flow:
- Separate beverages from the food using multiple coolers
- Place plates and utensils at the beginning of the line
- In order, arrange buns (if using), proteins, and side dishes
- Position condiments at the end
- Clear the table before setting out the dessert(s)
- Consider multiple serving lines for very large groups
- Put space between the food line and any amusements you’ve provided
Enjoy the Party!
Remember that your guests will remember the atmosphere and hospitality more than perfect execution. Stay relaxed, be present, and enjoy the gathering you’ve worked so hard to create.
Have a safe and wonderful Fourth!
Related Reads
4 Great Grilling Recipes to Use For a Small Group – Scaled-down but flavorful recipes like cider‑brined pork chops and Greek grilled shrimp.
8 Budget‑Friendly BBQ Recipes – Cost‑effective crowd-pleasers like whiskey‑brined pork shoulder and squash-black bean pizza.
Throw an Easy Barbecue Party – Tips for stress-free party planning with pulled pork, deviled eggs, and more.
Check out our 1000+ Recipes section here on Barbecue Bible.Com
Also, sign up for our Up in Smoke newsletter so you don’t miss any blogs and receive some special offers! PLUS get Raichlen’s Burgers! PDF for free!
Follow Steven on Facebook, Instagram, YouTube, TikTok, Reddit, and Pinterest!
Check out our store powered by BBQGuys!